Comparison: Shop Fox W1872 vs Dewalt DW788 Scroll Saw

Today, we’ll be delving into a comparison between two popular scroll saws: the Shop Fox W1872 and the Dewalt DW788 20-Inch models. Both of these saws are highly regarded in the woodworking community for their precision and performance. Let’s explore their features, capabilities, and which one might be the best fit for your woodworking projects.

Precision Crafting

Shop Fox W1872 Scroll Saw
Shop Fox W1872 Scroll Saw
BUY NOW
Amazon.com
8.4

The Shop Fox W1872 16″ VS Scroll Saw is a versatile and efficient tool equipped with a variable speed motor and a wide cutting capacity of up to 16″. With features like a foot switch, LED light, miter gauge, and rotary shaft, it offers precise cutting control and ease of use for a variety of woodworking projects.

Crafting Precision

Dewalt DW788 20-Inch Scroll Saw
Dewalt DW788 20-Inch Scroll Saw
BUY NOW
Amazon.com
9.1

The DEWALT Scroll Saw (DW788) offers precise cuts with reduced vibration and noise thanks to its double parallel link arm design. With exclusive tool-free blade clamps and convenient features like an electronic variable speed control, dust blower, and front arm design, this 20-inch saw provides smooth and efficient cutting performance.

Shop Fox W1872 Scroll Saw

Blade Material
High Speed Steel

Motor Power
1/6 HP, 120V, 0.6A

Blade Speed
550-1600 SPM

Max Cutting Thickness
2-1/4″

Special Features
Brake

Dewalt DW788 20-Inch Scroll Saw

Blade Material
Not specified

Motor Power
1.3 Amp

Blade Speed
Variable-Speed

Max Cutting Thickness
2″

Special Features
Tool-free blade clamps, dust blower

Shop Fox W1872 Scroll Saw

Benefits
  • Great value for the money
  • Well-made and suitable for beginners
  • Functions well with easy blade changing

Dewalt DW788 20-Inch Scroll Saw

Benefits
  • Good value for money
  • Very little vibration and quiet operation
  • Precise speed control with pinless blades for fine work

Shop Fox W1872 Scroll Saw

Drawbacks
  • Vibrations changed pattern and intensity without obvious cause
  • Light could be brighter

Dewalt DW788 20-Inch Scroll Saw

Drawbacks
  • Difficulty securing the bottom connection when installing a new blade
  • Lack of an attached light for intricate or prolonged work

Comparison

Shop Fox W1872 Scroll Saw vs Dewalt DW788 20-Inch Scroll Saw
Shop Fox W1872 Scroll Saw
VS
Dewalt DW788 20-Inch Scroll Saw
Blade Length
16 inches
VS
20 inches
Power
1.2 Amp
VS
1.3 Amp
Additional Features
Foot Switch, LED, Miter Gauge, Rotary Shaft
VS
Variable-Speed, Yellow Color
Ease of Use
Foot switch for convenient operation
VS
Variable-speed for precise cuts
Build Quality
Sturdy construction
VS
Durable design
Price
Moderate
VS
Higher-end

Shop Fox W1872 16″ VS Scroll Saw

  • USPs:
    • Foot switch for hands-free operation
    • LED light for better visibility
    • Miter gauge for angled cuts
  • Pros:
    • Convenient features for ease of use
    • Sturdy construction for durability
  • Cons:
    • Slightly lower power compared to DEWALT
  • Use-Cases:
    • Ideal for hobbyists and DIY enthusiasts

DEWALT DW788 20-Inch Scroll Saw

  • USPs:
    • Variable-speed control for versatile cutting
    • Vibrant yellow color for visibility
  • Pros:
    • High power output for efficient cutting
    • Precise variable-speed control
  • Cons:
    • Higher price point
  • Use-Cases:
    • Suitable for professional woodworkers

Based on the comparison, if you prioritize power and precision cutting, the DEWALT DW788 20-Inch Scroll Saw would be the clear choice. However, for hobbyists seeking user-friendly features at a more affordable price point, the Shop Fox W1872 16″ VS Scroll Saw is a great option.

In summary, the DEWALT DW788 excels in power and professional-grade performance, while the Shop Fox W1872 offers convenience and value for hobbyist woodworkers. Choose based on your specific needs and budget.

Comparing Scroll Saws: Key Factors and Guidelines

When comparing products in the Scroll Saw category, it’s essential to consider several key factors to ensure you make an informed decision. Below are some general guidelines to help you compare models like the Shop Fox W1872 Scroll Saw and the Dewalt DW788 20-Inch Scroll Saw effectively.

Key Factors to Consider:

  • Price: Compare the price of each scroll saw model to determine which offers the best value for your budget.
  • Specifications: Look at the specifications of each model, including motor power, throat size, and cutting capacity.
  • Build Quality: Assess the build quality of the scroll saws to ensure durability and reliability.
  • Features: Compare the features of each model, such as variable speed control, dust collection system, and blade change mechanism.
  • Brand Reputation: Consider the reputation of the brands (Shop Fox and Dewalt) to gauge reliability and customer satisfaction.
  • User Reviews: Read user reviews and feedback to get insights into the performance and user experience of each scroll saw.

Benefits of Shop Fox W1872 Scroll Saw:

  • Sturdy construction for stability during cutting.
  • Powerful motor for smooth and precise cuts.
  • Adjustable speed control for versatile cutting options.
  • Spacious work table for handling larger projects.
  • Good value for money considering its features.

Key Points of Dewalt DW788 20-Inch Scroll Saw:

  • Compact design for easy storage and portability.
  • Tool-free blade changes for quick and convenient operation.
  • Low vibration for enhanced precision and comfort during use.
  • Reliable brand with a reputation for quality tools.
  • Ideal for intricate and detailed woodworking projects.

By thoroughly comparing the Shop Fox W1872 Scroll Saw and the Dewalt DW788 20-Inch Scroll Saw based on these key factors and guidelines, you can choose the scroll saw that best fits your needs and preferences.

Scroll Saw FAQs

Can the Shop Fox W1872 and Dewalt DW788 scroll saws handle intricate cuts effectively?

Both the Shop Fox W1872 and Dewalt DW788 scroll saws are capable of handling intricate cuts effectively. They are designed with precision and versatility in mind, making them suitable for intricate woodworking projects. The variable-speed feature on the Dewalt DW788 allows for more control over cutting speeds, while the Shop Fox W1872 offers additional features like a foot switch, LED light, miter gauge, and rotary shaft to enhance cutting accuracy. Overall, both scroll saws are well-suited for intricate cuts in woodworking tasks.

What are the different types of blades used for scroll saws?

The different types of blades commonly used for scroll saws are:

  1. Skip-Tooth Blades: These blades have widely spaced teeth and are great for cutting soft materials like wood and plastic.
  2. Double-Tooth Blades: These blades have teeth that are paired closely together, providing a smoother cut and more precise results.
  3. Crown-Tooth Blades: These blades have teeth pointing in both directions, which allows for cutting in any direction without the need to rotate the workpiece.
  4. Spiral Blades: These blades have teeth all around, which makes them ideal for intricate and detailed cuts as they can cut in any direction without rotating the piece.

Each type of blade is designed for different cutting tasks and materials, so choosing the right blade for your project is essential for achieving the desired results.

What are the key differences between Shop Fox W1872 and Dewalt DW788 scroll saws?

Certainly! Here are the key differences between the Shop Fox W1872 and Dewalt DW788 scroll saws:

  1. Size: The Shop Fox W1872 has a 16-inch throat capacity, while the Dewalt DW788 has a larger 20-inch throat capacity.
  2. Power: The Dewalt DW788 has a 1.3 Amp motor, whereas the Shop Fox W1872 has a higher amperage motor, although the specific amperage is not mentioned.
  3. Features: The Shop Fox W1872 comes with additional features such as a foot switch, LED light, miter gauge, and rotary shaft, which are not included with the Dewalt DW788.

It’s important to consider these differences when choosing between the two scroll saw models based on your specific needs and preferences.

How do the prices of Shop Fox W1872 and Dewalt DW788 compare in terms of value for money?

In terms of value for money, the DEWALT DW788 tends to be more affordable compared to the Shop Fox W1872. Despite being priced lower, the DEWALT DW788 still offers excellent quality, performance, and features, making it a great choice for those looking for a reliable scroll saw without breaking the bank. On the other hand, the Shop Fox W1872 comes with additional features such as a foot switch, LED light, miter gauge, and rotary shaft, which may justify its higher price point for users who value these extras. Ultimately, the decision between the two will depend on your specific needs, budget, and preferences.

Which scroll saw is better suited for beginners – Shop Fox W1872 or Dewalt DW788?

Both the Shop Fox W1872 and Dewalt DW788 are excellent scroll saw options, but for beginners, the Dewalt DW788 may be better suited for a few reasons. The Dewalt DW788 has a reputation for being user-friendly and reliable, with its easy blade changes and smooth operation. Additionally, the larger 20-inch throat depth of the Dewalt DW788 provides more workspace compared to the 16-inch Shop Fox W1872, offering beginners more room to maneuver and work on their projects. Overall, the Dewalt DW788 may be a more beginner-friendly option due to its ease of use and larger working area.

«
»

3 responses to “Comparison: Shop Fox W1872 vs Dewalt DW788 Scroll Saw”

  1. Swift Avatar
    Swift

    Overall, this article provided a good starting point for anyone looking to purchase a scroll saw. I appreciate the effort put into comparing these two models.

  2. Whisper Avatar
    Whisper

    I wish there was more focus on the durability and long-term reliability of both scroll saws. It would have been helpful for making a more informed decision.

  3. Mirage Avatar
    Mirage

    I found the comparison between Shop Fox W1872 and Dewalt DW788 very informative. It helped me understand the key differences between the two models.