Battle of the Drills: BLACK+DECKER vs. Makita

Looking for the perfect drill to tackle your projects? Let’s dive into a comparison between the BLACK+DECKER 20V Drill and the Makita XPH12Z Hammer Drill. These two powerhouses offer different features and capabilities, so let’s explore which one might be the best fit for your needs!

DIY Projects

BLACK+DECKER 20V Drill
BLACK+DECKER 20V Drill
$41.65 $49.99 
as of April 12, 2024 11:00 am
BUY NOW
Amazon.com
9.3

The BLACK+DECKER 20V MAX* Cordless Drill (BCD702C1) offers precise screw control with its 11-position clutch and built-in driver bit holder for convenience. Powered by a 20V MAX* Lithium Ion battery, it provides strong performance and runtime, enhanced by an integrated LED light for visibility in dark spaces.

Professional Power

Makita XPH12Z Hammer Drill
Makita XPH12Z Hammer Drill
$142.90 $218.00 
as of April 12, 2024 11:00 am
BUY NOW
Amazon.com
9.3

The Makita XPH12Z 18V LXT Hammer Driver-Drill boasts a powerful brushless motor for up to 50% longer run time per charge, delivering 530 in.Lbs. of max torque. With a variable 2-speed design and efficient energy use, it’s ideal for a wide range of drilling, driving, and hammer applications.

BLACK+DECKER 20V Drill

Power Source
Battery Powered

Maximum Chuck Size
10 Millimeters

Maximum Power
1800 Watts

Included Components
Drill, Charger, Battery

Maximum Torque
N/A

Makita XPH12Z Hammer Drill

Power Source
Battery Powered

Maximum Chuck Size
0.5 Inches

Maximum Power
350 Watts

Included Components
Tool only (battery and charger not included)

Maximum Torque
530 Inch Pounds

BLACK+DECKER 20V Drill

Benefits
  • Lightweight and compact design
  • Good battery life and holds a charge well
  • Compatible with other Black & Decker 20V batteries

Makita XPH12Z Hammer Drill

Benefits
  • Great quality at a fair price
  • Powerful with impressive battery efficiency
  • Versatile and comfortable to use for various job applications

BLACK+DECKER 20V Drill

Drawbacks
  • No adapter for AU power socket
  • Battery life may be mediocre

Makita XPH12Z Hammer Drill

Drawbacks
  • No bit holder included
  • Expensive for what it is

Comparison chart

BLACK+DECKER 20V Drill vs Makita XPH12Z Hammer Drill
BLACK+DECKER 20V Drill
VS
Makita XPH12Z Hammer Drill
Voltage
20V
VS
18V
Brushless Motor
No
VS
Yes
Hammer Function
No
VS
Yes
Chuck Size
1/2″
VS
1/2″
Battery Included
Yes
VS
No
Weight
3.7 lbs
VS
4.2 lbs
Torque
283 in-lbs
VS
530 in-lbs
Speed
0-1,500 RPM
VS
0-500 & 0-2,000 RPM
LED Light
Yes
VS
Yes
Warranty
2-year limited
VS
3-year limited
Price
$ – $$
VS
$$ – $$$

BLACK+DECKER 20V MAX* Cordless Drill (BCD702C1):

  • USPs:
    • Lightweight design for easy handling.
    • Affordable price point.
  • Pros:
    • Battery included for immediate use.
  • Cons:
    • Lower torque compared to Makita.
  • Use-Cases:
    • Ideal for light to medium-duty tasks at home.

Makita XPH12Z 18V LXT Hammer Driver-Drill:

  • USPs:
    • Brushless motor for efficiency.
    • High torque for heavy-duty applications.
  • Pros:
    • Impressive torque for challenging tasks.
  • Cons:
    • Battery not included, higher price point.
  • Use-Cases:
    • Suitable for professional use and heavy-duty projects.

Conclusive Assessment:

  • For Light to Medium-Duty Tasks: BLACK+DECKER offers a budget-friendly option with basic features.
  • For Heavy-Duty and Professional Use: Makita’s superior torque and brushless motor make it a top choice.

Final Summary:

  • Recommendation: Choose BLACK+DECKER for casual DIY projects or Makita for professional-grade tasks requiring higher power and durability.

Comparing Cordless Drills: Key Factors to Consider

When choosing between cordless drills such as the BLACK+DECKER 20V Drill and the Makita XPH12Z Hammer Drill, it’s important to consider several factors to ensure you make an informed decision. Here are some general guidelines and key points to help you compare these products effectively:

Power and Performance

  • Voltage: Higher voltage typically means more power.
  • Torque: Consider the torque rating for the tasks you’ll be doing.
  • Speed Settings: Variable speed settings offer versatility.

Battery Life and Charging

  • Battery Type: Lithium-ion batteries are preferred for longer life.
  • Charging Time: Faster charging can be a significant advantage.
  • Battery Compatibility: Check if batteries are interchangeable with other tools.

Design and Ergonomics

  • Weight and Size: Consider the tool’s weight for extended use.
  • Handle Comfort: Ergonomic design reduces fatigue.
  • LED Lights: Built-in lights can improve visibility in dimly lit areas.

Features and Functionality

  • Chuck Type: Keyless chucks offer convenience.
  • Clutch Settings: Adjustable clutch settings for different applications.
  • Hammer Function: Important for drilling into masonry.

Brand Reputation and Warranty

  • Brand Reputation: Established brands often offer better quality.
  • Warranty: Longer warranties provide peace of mind.

By considering these factors and comparing them between the BLACK+DECKER 20V Drill and the Makita XPH12Z Hammer Drill, you can make a well-informed decision based on your specific needs and preferences.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) about Cordless Drills

How long does the battery usually last on a cordless drill?

The battery life of a cordless drill can vary depending on usage, but typically, the BLACK+DECKER 20V MAX Cordless Drill (BCD702C1) can last around 2-3 hours on a full charge, while the Makita XPH12Z 18V LXT Lithium-Ion Brushless Cordless Hammer Driver-Drill can last approximately 1-2 hours. These estimates are based on moderate use and may vary based on the specific tasks and settings being used.

Are there significant differences in performance between BLACK+DECKER and Makita drills?

Both BLACK+DECKER and Makita are reputable brands known for their quality power tools. When comparing the specific models mentioned, the BLACK+DECKER 20V MAX Cordless Drill and the Makita XPH12Z 18V LXT Hammer Driver-Drill, it’s important to note that they are designed for different voltage systems (20V vs. 18V).

In terms of performance, Makita generally has a reputation for producing high-performance power tools, and their brushless motor technology is often considered top-notch. On the other hand, BLACK+DECKER is known for providing reliable tools at a more budget-friendly price point.

However, the performance differences between these two specific drills may vary depending on the tasks they are used for and the user’s preferences. It’s recommended to review detailed specifications, user reviews, and possibly even test the drills yourself to determine which one would best suit your needs.

Are brushless motors worth the extra cost in a cordless drill?

Brushless motors are worth the extra cost in a cordless drill for several reasons. They are more efficient, provide longer run times, generate less heat, and typically have a longer lifespan compared to brushed motors. This means you’ll get more power and durability out of your cordless drill with a brushless motor, making it a worthwhile investment in the long run. Both the BLACK+DECKER 20V MAX* Cordless Drill and the Makita XPH12Z 18V LXT Lithium-Ion Brushless Cordless 1/2″ Hammer Driver-Drill are great options that feature brushless motors for enhanced performance.

How do the prices of BLACK+DECKER and Makita drills compare?

When comparing the prices of the BLACK+DECKER 20V MAX* Cordless Drill (BCD702C1) and the Makita XPH12Z 18V LXT Lithium-Ion Brushless Cordless 1/2″ Hammer Driver-Drill (Tool Only), the Makita drill tends to be priced higher than the BLACK+DECKER drill. This price difference is due to various factors such as brand reputation, features, and overall build quality. It’s important to consider your specific needs and budget when choosing between the two drills.

Which brand provides superior battery life in their drills, BLACK+DECKER or Makita?

In terms of battery life, Makita generally provides superior battery life in their drills compared to BLACK+DECKER. This is due to Makita’s advanced lithium-ion battery technology and efficient brushless motors, which help to extend the runtime of their drills. However, it’s important to note that battery life can also vary depending on factors like usage conditions and the specific model of the drill.

Which drill brand offers better durability, BLACK+DECKER or Makita?

In terms of durability between BLACK+DECKER and Makita drills, Makita is generally considered to offer better durability. Makita is known for its high-quality construction and long-lasting performance in tough work environments. While BLACK+DECKER drills are also reliable, Makita is often favored for its durability and longevity.

What are the key factors to consider when choosing a cordless drill?

When choosing a cordless drill, there are several key factors to consider:

  1. Voltage: Higher voltage typically means more power. The BLACK+DECKER 20V MAX* Cordless Drill has a 20V battery, while the Makita XPH12Z has an 18V battery.
  2. Battery Type and Capacity: Lithium-ion batteries are preferred for their longer runtime and fade-free power. Consider the battery capacity for longer-lasting performance.
  3. Brushless Motor: Brushless motors are more efficient, provide more power, and have a longer lifespan compared to brushed motors. The Makita XPH12Z features a brushless motor.
  4. Chuck Size: The chuck size determines the maximum size of the drill bit the drill can accommodate. Both drills have a 1/2″ chuck size.
  5. Ergonomics and Weight: Consider the design of the drill for comfort during extended use. A lightweight and ergonomically designed drill can reduce fatigue.
  6. Additional Features: Look for features like variable speed settings, built-in LED lights, and belt clips for added convenience.

By considering these factors, you can choose the cordless drill that best suits your needs and preferences between the BLACK+DECKER 20V MAX* Cordless Drill and the Makita XPH12Z.

«
»

7 responses to “Battle of the Drills: BLACK+DECKER vs. Makita”

  1. Ace Avatar
    Ace

    Interesting article, I wonder if the price difference is worth it for Makita.

  2. Echo Avatar
    Echo

    Looking forward to seeing the durability test results, that’s a key factor for me.

  3. Spark Avatar
    Spark

    BLACK+DECKER is known for being budget-friendly, curious to see if it holds up against Makita.

  4. Willow Avatar
    Willow

    I’ve had bad experiences with BLACK+DECKER tools in the past, hoping this article sheds some light.

  5. Zara Avatar
    Zara

    I wish the article included more technical specifications for both drills.

  6. Sky Avatar
    Sky

    I have always been a Makita fan, excited to see this comparison!

  7. Blaze Avatar
    Blaze

    Great comparison, I’m leaning towards Makita but still open to being convinced otherwise.