DEWALT XR Circular Saw vs Makita 5007F Saw Comparison

When it comes to power tools, the DEWALT XR Circular Saw and the Makita 5007F Saw are two heavyweights in the world of cutting efficiency and precision. Both renowned for their durability and performance, these saws cater to professionals and DIY enthusiasts alike. Let’s delve into a comparison of their features and capabilities to help you determine which one best suits your cutting needs.

Precision Power

DEWALT XR Circular Saw
DEWALT XR Circular Saw

The DEWALT 20V MAX* XR Circular Saw with Power Detect offers up to 54% more power for efficient cutting. With a maximum depth of cut of 2-9/16 inches at 90 degrees and convenient features like an electric brake and LED light, this cordless saw is a versatile and practical tool for precision cutting tasks.

Precision Powerhouse

Makita 5007F Saw
Makita 5007F Saw

The Makita 5007F Circular Saw features a powerful 15 AMP motor and large cutting capacity, making it ideal for framers, builders, and siding contractors. With a well-balanced design, LED lights for accuracy, and convenient blade replacement, it offers superior handling and durability for a variety of cutting tasks.

DEWALT XR Circular Saw

Power Source
Battery Powered

Item Weight
7.9 pounds

Blade Length
4 Inches

Special Features
Brake, Brushless

Cutting Capacity
2-9/16″ at 90°

Makita 5007F Saw

Power Source
Hand Powered

Item Weight
13.57 pounds

Blade Length
4 Inches

Special Features

Cutting Capacity
2-3/8″ at 90°

DEWALT XR Circular Saw

  • Good run time
  • Comes with battery, charger, case, and blade
  • Powerful and well-made

Makita 5007F Saw

  • Powerful cutting performance
  • Lightweight and well-balanced
  • Durable and easy to repair

DEWALT XR Circular Saw

  • Safety guard is plastic
  • Heavy

Makita 5007F Saw

  • Arm gets sore after multiple cuts in a row
  • Little heavy

Feature comparison chart

DEWALT XR Circular Saw vs Makita 5007F Saw
DEWALT XR Circular Saw
Makita 5007F Saw
Power Source
Blade Size
7-1/4 inches
7-1/4 inches
Brushless Motor
Tool Technology
Power Detect
8.75 lbs
11.1 lbs
Max Speed (RPM)
Bevel Capacity
57 degrees
56 degrees
3 years limited
1 year

Product Comparison:

DEWALT 20V MAX* XR Circular Saw:

  • USPs:
    • Brushless motor for enhanced efficiency.
    • Power Detect technology maximizes performance.
  • Pros:
    • Lightweight design for ease of use.
    • Impressive warranty coverage.
  • Cons:
    • Battery-dependent power source may require recharging.
  • Use-Cases:
    • Ideal for contractors needing portability and power.

Makita 5007F Circular Saw:

  • USPs:
    • Corded power source for consistent performance.
    • Higher RPM for faster cutting.
  • Pros:
    • Durable construction for longevity.
    • Cost-effective option compared to battery-powered saws.
  • Cons:
    • Heavier weight may be less comfortable for extended use.
  • Use-Cases:
    • Suited for workshop settings where power source availability is not an issue.

Conclusive Assessment:

  • Clear Winner: DEWALT 20V MAX* XR Circular Saw excels in portability and modern technology.
  • Conditional Winner: Choose Makita 5007F for consistent power in workshop environments.

Final Summary:

Based on the comparison, the DEWALT 20V MAX* XR Circular Saw is recommended for users prioritizing mobility and advanced features, while the Makita 5007F Circular Saw is ideal for those seeking reliable performance in workshop settings. Choose based on your specific needs and preferences.

Guidelines for Comparing Circular Saws

When comparing circular saws like the DEWALT XR Circular Saw and the Makita 5007F Saw, it’s important to consider several key factors to make an informed decision. Here are some general guidelines to help you evaluate and compare these products effectively:

Power and Performance

  • Check the amperage and RPM of the saws for power comparison.
  • Look at the cutting capacity and depth of cut to determine the saws’ performance.

Design and Ergonomics

  • Consider the weight and balance of the saw for comfortable use.
  • Evaluate the handle design and grip for ease of control.

Features and Functionality

  • Compare the presence of features like laser guides, dust collection, and electric brakes.
  • Check for compatibility with accessories and additional functionalities.

Durability and Build Quality

  • Assess the materials used in construction for durability.
  • Look for features like magnesium components for lightweight yet robust construction.

Brand Reputation and Warranty

  • Research the reputation of the brands in terms of quality and customer service.
  • Compare the warranty offered for each product to ensure long-term support.

By considering these factors and guidelines, you’ll be able to compare circular saws like the DEWALT XR and Makita 5007F effectively and choose the one that best fits your needs.

Circular Saw FAQs

How do you choose the right circular saw for your project?

When choosing the right circular saw for your project, there are several factors to consider. Firstly, assess the power source – the DEWALT DCS574W1 is a cordless saw powered by a 20V MAX* battery, offering portability and convenience, while the Makita 5007F is a corded saw. Secondly, consider blade size – both saws have a 7-1/4″ blade, suitable for various cutting depths. Lastly, look at additional features such as brushless motors for increased efficiency (DEWALT) or specific design elements that may suit your cutting needs (Makita). Ultimately, choose the saw that aligns best with your project requirements and preferences.

How do the DEWALT XR Circular Saw and Makita 5007F Saw compare in terms of power?

Both the DEWALT XR Circular Saw and Makita 5007F Saw are powerful tools in their respective categories. The DEWALT XR Circular Saw operates on 20V MAX power with a brushless motor and Power Detect Technology, providing enhanced performance. On the other hand, the Makita 5007F Saw is known for its 15-amp motor that delivers robust cutting power. While both are excellent choices for cutting tasks, the DEWALT XR Circular Saw may offer slightly more advanced power features due to its brushless motor and innovative technology.

What are the key differences in design between the DEWALT XR Circular Saw and Makita 5007F Saw?

The key differences in design between the DEWALT XR Circular Saw and the Makita 5007F Saw lie in their specific features and ergonomics.

  1. DEWALT XR Circular Saw:
  • Features Power Detect Tool Technology for maximizing performance when used with high-capacity XR batteries.
  • Brushless motor for increased efficiency and runtime.
  • The tool boasts a 7-1/4-inch blade size for versatile cutting applications.
  • Ergonomic design with a comfortable grip for prolonged usage.
  1. Makita 5007F Circular Saw:
  • Lightweight design for improved maneuverability on the job.
  • Equipped with a 7-1/4-inch blade size for various cutting tasks.
  • Built-in dust blower for enhanced visibility of the cutting line.
  • Large ergonomic handle for comfortable operation.

By considering these differences, you can choose the circular saw that best suits your specific cutting needs and preferences.

Which saw offers better precision and accuracy: DEWALT XR Circular Saw or Makita 5007F Saw?

Both the DEWALT XR Circular Saw and the Makita 5007F Saw are reputable brands known for their quality and performance. However, if we compare precision and accuracy between the two models, the Makita 5007F Saw is often praised for its excellent precision and accuracy. The Makita saw is known for its smooth and clean cuts, making it a popular choice among professionals who prioritize accuracy in their work. So, if precision is a top priority for you, the Makita 5007F Saw may be the better option.

Can you explain the differences in price between the DEWALT XR Circular Saw and Makita 5007F Saw?

The price difference between the DEWALT XR Circular Saw and the Makita 5007F Saw can be attributed to several factors. Firstly, the brand reputation and market positioning of each company can influence pricing. DEWALT is known for its high-quality, professional-grade tools, which may reflect in a higher price point compared to Makita, which also offers quality tools but may target a different market segment. Secondly, the specific features and technology incorporated in each saw model can impact the cost. The DEWALT XR Circular Saw with Power Detect Tool Technology may have more advanced features or functionalities that justify a higher price tag compared to the Makita 5007F Saw. Additionally, differences in manufacturing processes, materials used, and overall build quality can also contribute to variations in pricing between the two products.

What are the key safety tips for using a circular saw?

When using a circular saw like the DEWALT 20V MAX* XR or the Makita 5007F, it’s important to follow key safety tips:

  1. Always wear proper safety gear, including safety glasses, hearing protection, and gloves.
  2. Ensure the blade guard is functioning properly and covers the blade when not in use.
  3. Keep your hands away from the cutting area and always use a push stick when necessary.
  4. Secure your workpiece properly before cutting to prevent kickback.
  5. Disconnect the saw from power when changing blades or making adjustments.
  6. Follow the manufacturer’s instructions and guidelines for safe operation.

By following these safety tips, you can minimize the risk of accidents and work more confidently with your circular saw.


8 responses to “DEWALT XR Circular Saw vs Makita 5007F Saw Comparison”

  1. Blaze Avatar

    The article could benefit from including a section on warranty and customer support for the saws.

  2. Frost Avatar

    I found the discussion on durability and build quality insightful.

  3. Midnight Avatar

    The comparison of price points between the two saws is very helpful for decision-making.

  4. Phoenix Avatar

    Thanks for the detailed breakdown of the key differences between these two popular saw models.

  5. Serenity Avatar

    It would be great to see a section on user reviews and experiences with these saws.

  6. Rebel Rose Avatar
    Rebel Rose

    This article provides a comprehensive comparison between the DEWALT XR and Makita 5007F saws.

  7. Zenith Avatar

    I wish there was more information on the blade quality and cutting precision of each saw.

  8. Whisper Avatar

    Overall, a well-written and informative comparison for anyone looking to purchase a circular saw.